If you’re dealing with eye strain from working on your computer in dim lighting, choosing the right lighting equipment can really help. But with so many options, like desk lamps vs monitor lamps, it can be confusing to decide which is best. This article will explore the pros and cons of both options, helping you understand which type of light might best suit your needs.
| Desk Lamp
|
Monitor Lamp
|
|
| Minimal desk lamp | ❌ | ✅ |
| Low Screen Glare | ❌ | ✅ |
| Optimal Beam Distribution | ❌ | ✅ |
| Adjustable Options | ✅ | ❌ |
| Wide Style Range | ✅ | ❌ |
| Most Budget-Friendly | ✅ | ❌ |
What is a Desk Lamp?
A desk lamp is like an overhead fluorescent bulb that shines light downward onto your workspace. It’s commonly used on tables or desks to brighten specific areas. Desk lamps come in various shapes like rectangular, square, round, and triangular, and some even have adjustable arms so you can change the height of the light as needed.
Features of Desk Lamp
A desk lamp is perfect for brightening up a specific area, like your bedside table, making reading easier and more comfortable. It helps reduce eye strain from screens by providing focused light, which can also improve your mood and productivity. Plus, with interchangeable bulbs, you can easily switch to different types, like smart or RGB, to match your style and needs.
However, desk lamps can cause screen glare, making it hard to see your monitor and affecting your work. They can also be bulky and clutter up your desk with cables, and their positioning might block your view. Additionally, desk lamps often don’t provide even lighting, casting shadows and making it tricky to work.
Pros & Cons
The table below highlights the pros and cons of desk lamps, making it easy to see their advantages and disadvantages at a glance.
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
What is a Monitor Lamp?
A monitor lamp is a compact light that clips onto your monitor's top or sides. It brightens your desk area and reduces glare, making your workspace more comfortable and efficient. It’s a modern, space-saving alternative to traditional desk lamps, designed to improve desk lighting without taking up extra space.
Features of Monitor Lamp
Monitor lamps are perfect for saving desk space as they attach directly to your monitor, keeping your desk clear. They provide even, shadow-free lighting ideal for wide desks and reduce screen glare by directing light away from the screen. Plus, they’re easy to set up with a simple USB connection, making cable management a breeze.
Monitor lamps have a few drawbacks. Their LED lights can’t be replaced, so you’ll need a new lamp if they fail. They can also block webcam placement, making setups tricky if you use one. Plus, they depend on your monitor’s USB port for power, so they turn off if your monitor sleeps, which can be inconvenient.
Pros & Cons
The table below lists the pros and cons of monitor lamps. This simple overview helps you weigh their benefits and drawbacks quickly and easily.
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
In the battle between a desk lamp and a monitor lamp, each has unique advantages tailored to your needs. We’ll compare both options to help you find the best light for your workspace. Say goodbye to squinting and hello to the ultimate lighting solution for a brighter, more comfortable workspace right now!
| Characters | Desk Lamps | Monitor Lamps | Winner |
| Screen Glare or Reflections | Can result In screen glare | Zero screen glare or reflections | Monitor Lamp |
| Desk Space Usage |
|
|
Monitor Lamp |
| Versatility | Position a desk lamp anywhere | Fixed to the top of your monitor | Desk Lamp |
| Light Temperature Brightness | Have fixed bulbs | Switch between different light colors | Monitor Lamp |
| Compatibility | Don’t interfere with monitor-mounted gadgets | Conflict with other tech such as a webcam | Desk Lamp |
| Power Source | Plug directly into a wall outlet | Only work when the computer is on | Desk Lamp |
| Reach and Illumination |
|
|
Desk Lamp |
| Conserve Energy | Use 60 watts or more to achieve the same brightness | Use just 1 - 5 watts of electricity | Monitor Lamp |
| Placement | Sit on one side of your desk | Mounted directly on your monitor | Desk Lamp |
| Cost | More affordable | Higher cost | Desk Lamp |
Winner: Monitor Lamp
A desk lamp can sometimes cause glare on your computer screen because its light may reflect directly off the monitor, creating annoying bright spots. This glare can make it difficult to see what you're working on and strain your eyes.
Many people think glare on screens is impossible to avoid, but that's not true. While it's hard to completely eliminate glare from TVs, computers, and tablets, monitor light bars can help. These light bars are designed with small, asymmetric designs, and evenly spaced LEDs that control light distribution, ensuring there’s no harsh glare on your screen. Moreover, monitor lamps direct light precisely, cutting off the beam sharply as it approaches your monitor.
*Note: Monitor light bars are made to reduce glare, but some might still let light bleed. To avoid this, pick a light bar with an asymmetrical design and adjust its angle and position for the best results.
Winner: Monitor Lamp
Both desk lamps vs monitor lamps offer reliable lighting for your workspace, but they differ in how they use desk space. Desk lamps can take up much room because they require more space for their bases and additional power cords. This can be a hassle on smaller desks and might limit space for your laptop or books.
On the other hand, monitor lamps are a great choice for saving desk space and keeping things tidy. They sit right on your monitor, which is perfect for smaller setups. Plus, these LED-powered light bars use minimal electricity and often plug into your monitor’s USB port. This setup reduces cable clutter and eliminates the need for extra power adapters, making your desk look neat and organized.
Winner: Desk Lamp
In terms of versatility, desk lamps have the advantage of being easily movable and adjustable. You can position a desk lamp anywhere on your desk and direct the light exactly where you need it, which is useful for various tasks like reading or writing. Desk lamps also illuminate a larger area, making them ideal for oversized desks or tasks that require broader lighting.
On the other hand, monitor lamps are fixed to the top of your monitor and have limited adjustability, often focusing light just in front of the screen. Besides, monitor light bars make typing easier by providing extra light to your keyboard. If you often type in dim settings or have a keyboard without backlighting, a monitor light bar can help you see the keys better and make typing more comfortable.
Winner: Monitor Lamp
When it comes to adjusting light temperature, monitor light bars have a clear edge. They let you easily switch between different light colors, whether you prefer a bright, white light or a softer, warm glow, all with just a button press. For example, if you're working on a project that needs focused, bright light, you can set it to that, but if you want a cozy, warm light for reading, you can switch to that too.
In contrast, most traditional desk lamps are less flexible. They usually have fixed bulbs, so if you want a different light temperature, you'll need to replace the bulb with one that suits your preference. You can switch your desk lamp bulb to LED, CFL, Halogen, or types like E14 or E27. Our detailed articles compare these options, helping you choose the best bulb for your needs.
Related articles:
Winner: Desk lamps
One key point between a desk lamp vs monitor lamp is their compatibility with other tech, like webcams. Monitor lamps are designed to sit directly on top of your monitor, right in the center. This placement can conflict with a webcam, which is often mounted in the same spot.
Desk lamps, on the other hand, sit on your desk and don’t interfere with monitor-mounted gadgets, giving you more flexibility.
Winner: Desk lamps
Desk lamps usually plug directly into a wall outlet, which ensures they work anytime and offer more reliable power. This also means you don’t have to worry about your monitor being on, making desk lamps a more practical choice for consistent lighting.
On the other hand, monitor lamps usually use the monitor’s USB port for power, but this can be inconvenient. Not all monitors have USB ports, and the monitor needs to be on for the light to work. For example, if someone wants to use their monitor light while their computer is off, they might struggle. They might even need to turn on their computer just to power the light.
Winner: Desk Lamp
Desk lamps usually come out on top in the battle between a desk lamp vs monitor lamp for reach and illumination. E-reading LED desk lamps are especially great because they provide bright light for your entire desk and are priced similarly to monitor lamps. Additionally, they can cover a larger area and be adjusted to different positions for various tasks or a wider lighting area.
In contrast, monitor lamps focus their light directly onto the monitor, offering a more concentrated but limited illumination. Another issue with monitor lamps is keyboard glare, where light reflects off your keyboard at certain angles, making the text harder to read, especially on glossy keys. However, this is generally not a deal-breaker, as you can adjust some variables like your keyboard angle, sitting height, and monitor distance to reduce this problem.
Winner: Monitor lamp
Monitor light bars are much more efficient than traditional desk lamps. Monitor light bars typically use just 1 - 5 watts of electricity, which is very low, while a monitor light bar provides adequate lighting with minimal energy.
On the contrary, a standard incandescent desk lamp might use 60 watts or more to achieve the same brightness. This means that using a monitor light bar can significantly reduce your energy consumption and lower your electricity bills.
Related articles:
Winner: Monitor Lamp
Desk lamps typically sit on one side of your desk, which means the light comes from just that side. This can be a bit awkward if your desk setup is centered. Besides, desk lamps are often found in living rooms, providing extra light for your activities. So, where to put a lamp in the living room to enhance its style and function? Check out our article to find the perfect spot for your lamp!
On the other hand, a monitor light bar is mounted directly on your monitor, providing light right where you need it. Since your monitor is usually in front of you, the light is perfectly centered, making it much more convenient for your workspace.
Winner: Desk Lamp
When comparing costs, desk lamps generally come out cheaper than monitor light bars. Desk lamps are just simpler devices, with just a light bulb, socket, and switch inside a lampshade. For example, a standard desk lamp might cost around $20 to $30.
On the other hand, monitor light bars are more advanced and often feature additional functions like adjustable brightness and color temperature, which makes them pricier. Basic models start around $30 to $40, while high-end options can reach up to $180.
|
Desk lamps offer versatility, broad illumination, and adjustable placement, making them suitable for various tasks. They typically plug into wall outlets and are more affordable. In contrast, monitor light bars save desk space and plug directly into your computer, which is convenient for setups with multiple devices. They provide focused light on the keyboard, ideal for late-night work without backlighting, while also reducing screen glare and conserving energy. However, monitor light bars are generally less versatile and may come at a higher price. |
When choosing between a desk lamp vs monitor lamp, consider what is important to you. A desk lamp is versatile, connects to a wall outlet for power, and provides better reach and illumination. It’s also cost-effective and compatible with various setups. On the other hand, a monitor lamp is great for reducing screen glare or reflections and can help conserve energy. Ultimately, it depends on your workspace preferences and needs!
Tags:
If you’re dealing with eye strain from working on your computer in dim lighting, choosing the right lighting equipment can really help. But with so many options, like desk lamps vs monitor lamps, it can be confusing to decide which is best. This article will explore the pros and cons of both options, helping you […]
End table vs side table might look similar, but they serve different purposes and come in varying sizes. End tables usually sit next to a chair or at the ends of a sofa, with smaller tabletops ranging from 12 to 18 inches wide. In contrast, side tables are often placed beside seating areas or against […]
When it comes to comparing LED lights vs halogen lights, LED lights outshine halogen bulbs with unmatched energy efficiency, durability, and environmental friendliness. While halogen bulbs might have a lower upfront cost, LED lights offer substantial long-term savings and better performance. Features Light Emitting Diode (LED) Halogen Lights Technology Solid-state semiconductor Incandescent gas-filled bulb Light […]
When choosing between LED lights vs CFL lights, it’s helpful to know how they differ. LED lights are widely used due to their energy efficiency and longevity. CFL lights, while also energy-saving and typically less expensive initially, have a shorter life and contain small amounts of mercury. In this article, we'll break down other differences […]
Desk lamp vs table lamp is a popular must-have interior that can be found in any home or workplace. Be confused when starting to learn about desk lamps vs table lamps as they look the same at the first glance? Just understanding key differences in size, style, and functionality and you be a professional in […]
