Are Keycaps Universal? How to Find Keycaps That Fit Your Mechanical Keyboard

  • Keycaps 101
  • Posted by: carson-rutz
  • Sep 5, 2024

The short answer is no, keycaps are not one-size-fits-all switches. Keycap compatibility depends on factors such as the switch type, keycap profile, and keyboard layout. While Cherry MX-style switches are common, all keycaps may not fit on all keyboards or switch types. Our article will explore the factors that affect keycap compatibility and help you find the best keycaps for your keyboard.

Are keycaps universal?

How to find keycaps that fit mechanical keyboard
How to find keycaps that fit mechanical keyboard

No, keycaps are not universal. The fit of keycaps varies based on several factors such as switch type, keyboard layout, and the keycap profile. While Cherry MX-style switches are the most common and compatible with a wide range of keycaps, other switches like Topre, low Choc, or Alps may require specific keycap designs, limiting compatibility options.
The variability in keycap size, shape, and design means that not all keycaps will fit every keyboard. Different keyboards have unique layouts and key sizes, particularly for larger keys like the spacebar and enter key. Therefore, when purchasing keycaps, you need to make sure they are designed to fit your keyboard’s specific switch and layout.

Are keycaps universal
Are keycaps universal?

7 Factors Affecting Keycap Compatibility

Keycap Size Compatibility

Keyboard form factors and layouts
General keycaps layout

Keycaps are not the same size. Different keyboard layouts come with a variety of keycap sizes, especially for larger keys like the shift, enter keys, or standard spacebar size. For example, the right shift key can be 1.75u on some keyboards and 2.75u on others. Other keys, such as the spacebar, may vary between 6.25u and 7u depending on the layout. So, how to know if keycaps will fit? Always verify keycap sizes and consult a dimensions guide to make sure the keycaps will fit your keyboard.
If you're unsure about the sizes of your keyboard, checking a keycap dimensions guide is essential. Some popular layouts, such as full-sized, TKL, or 60% keyboards, all have distinct keycap size variations. To dive deeper into understanding keycap dimensions, you can explore this keycap dimensions guide for beginners to help identify the right fit for your keyboard.

Keycap Height

Keyboard form factors and layouts
Keycap compatibility: height

Most keyboards on the market share the same height ("OEM" profile). This is the standard keycap profile for keyboards. Also, the OEM profile is known for its iconic flat top, a slant to support the user's fingertips, and a slight cylindrical bow.

Spacebar Compatibility

Keyboard form factors and layouts
Spacebar compatibility

The most popular spacebar length of all is around 6.25 units, which is roughly 158mm long measured from the bottom of the spacebar.

Modifier Compatibility

Keyboard form factors and layouts
Modifier compatibility

Here are some of the most common modifier layouts for keyboards:

  • Green = Compatible.
  • Yellow = Not standard, but available upon request.
  • Red = Not compatible. Size not available.

Caps Lock Compatibility

A caps lock is the lock key found on most keyboards. It is located in R3 and usually around 1.75u.

Enter Key Compatibility

Enter Key or the keyboard's Return key can come in all shapes and sizes, from the backwards-L shape, J-Shaped Enter key to a simple rectangular.

Right Shift Compatibility

Keyboards that have a compact design usually come with a smaller right shift. This makes the right shift keycap sizes differ on each layout. Additionally, some can also be on different rows too. The right shift is available from 1.75u to a full 2.75u.

Key Stem

Well, this is basically the plastic part that connects your switch to the keycap. And, the type of stem defines what keycaps you can use on your keyboard. The most common one is the Cherry MX which has a cross-shaped stem.

Keycap Profile

Keycap profiles come in many different shapes and heights
Keycap profiles come in many different shapes and heights

Keycap profiles refer to the shape and height of the keycaps, which influence typing comfort, feel, and performance. Here is a table that highlights popular keycap profiles and their unique features:

Keycap Profile Features
Cherry Profile Sculpted rows with angled tops, low profile (9.4mm), popular for speed and comfort
OEM Medium height (11.9mm), commonly found on pre-built keyboards, suitable for general use
SA Tall (16.5mm), spherical tops, ideal for those who prefer a vintage feel
DSA Low profile (7.6mm), flat and uniform, preferred for fast typing
XDA Flat tops, uniform across all rows, medium height (9.1mm), great for smooth typing

Each profile offers a unique typing experience. Read this Guide to Different Keycap Profiles for a more in-depth understanding of keycap profiles.

Switch Type 

Popular brands offer a variety of mechanical keyboard switch types with their own style (source: switch and click)
Popular brands offer a variety of mechanical keyboard switch types with their own style (source: switch and click)

Not all keycaps fit all switches, and not all switches are compatible with every keycap set. Cherry MX switches are the most common type, and they are compatible with most keycap sets. However, switches like Topre, Kailh, Gateron, and others may have different designs, requiring specific keycaps or adapters to ensure keycaps will fit your keyboard properly. Below is a table summarizing the key characteristics of popular switches:

Switch Type Features
Cherry MX Most common, compatible with most keycaps, various tactile and linear options
Kailh Similar to Cherry MX, offers unique Box switches for dust and water resistance
Gateron Known for smoother keystrokes, Cherry MX-compatible, popular with people unlike the “scratchy”
Topre Uses a rubber dome mechanism, not compatible with Cherry MX keycaps without adapters
Razer Designed for gaming, tactile and clicky options, usually only compatible with Razer keycaps

To explore more details about different switch types, check out this Guide to Mechanical Keyboard Switches or compare Cherry MX vs Gateron vs Kailh.

Keyboard Layout 

There are six common types of keyboard sizes generally mass-produced (source: keychron)
There are six common types of keyboard sizes generally mass-produced (source: keychron)

The layout of a keyboard determines the size and position of each key, which directly impacts keycap compatibility. Different layouts can require different keycap sizes, especially for larger or less common keys like the enter, shift, and spacebar. Standard layouts are the most common and typically follow established formats like ANSI, ISO, and JIS. These layouts generally make it easier to find compatible keycap sets:

  • QWERTY: The most common layout worldwide, designed for typewriters and now the standard for most keyboards.
  • AZERTY: Primarily used in French-speaking countries, it rearranges some letters and symbols to fit the French language better.
  • QWERTZ: Common in Germany and Central Europe, this layout swaps the "Z" and "Y" keys to suit the German language.
  • Dvorak: Designed for efficient typing by placing the most frequently used letters on the home row to reduce finger movement.
  • Colemak: An ergonomic alternative to QWERTY, minimizing finger movement and increasing typing comfort.
  • Split Keyboards: These divide the keyboard into two halves, promoting a more natural hand position and reducing strain.
  • Ergonomic Keyboards: Designed with curved or split layouts to improve hand and wrist posture during extended typing sessions.
  • Programmable Keyboards: Users can customize the function of each key, offering flexibility for specific tasks or gaming setups.
  • Minimalist Keyboards: Focus on compact design, often eliminating non-essential keys to save space and create a clean look.
  • Touchscreens: While not traditional keyboards, touchscreen keyboards offer an alternative input method on mobile devices and some laptops, adapting dynamically to various layouts.

Whether you're after comfort, speed, or a sleek minimalist setup, this guide on keyboard sizes and layouts will help you make the right choice.

Keycap Material and Quality 

The master sword artisan keycap is handmade with premium materials to ensure durability
The master sword artisan keycap is handmade with premium materials to ensure durability

Keycap material plays a significant role in durability and feel. The most common materials are ABS and PBT. ABS keycaps are affordable and smooth but tend to become shiny over time. In contrast, PBT keycaps are more durable and resistant to wear, offering a matte texture that doesn’t develop shine as quickly.

Quality also matters when choosing keycaps. Well-made keycaps will fit securely on switches, ensuring stability during typing. Poorly manufactured keycaps, regardless of material, may have fitting issues, causing them to feel loose or wobbly. Always opt for high-quality keycaps to avoid potential compatibility and performance problems.

Stabilizer

Stabilizers are created to keep the keys from shaking, rattling, and tilting when typing or gaming. You easily see them under the larger keys such as space bar, backspace, and shift when switching keycaps. This is one of the key features that decides if your keycaps will fit your keyboard. We've listed a few common stabilizer types out there below:

  • Cherry Style Stabilizers. These versatile stabilizers come with the famous Cherry MX switch stem. Generally, they are easy to make and have tons of styles, colors, and material options.
  • Costar Stabilizers. Less common than the Cherry style, you will have more chances to find these costar stabilizers on older keyboards than the modern ones. They are not easy to use because you have to hook them into the keycap to fit.
  • Optical Stabilizers. Typically found on keyboards with optical switches, the optical stabilizers have a very funky design. For these stabilizers to work, you will need to insert the clip into the keycap and then snap them into the stabilizer bar.

Backlight Compatibility

Backlit keycaps
Backlight keycap compatibility

When looking for a new keycap set, you will want to make sure the set thickness, material, and profile are suitable for the backlight. For example, if you are using RGB lighting, then you will need keycaps that are double-shot, clear, or pudding style to allow the light to shine through. So, don't forget to check if your new keycaps are backlit support or not.

How To Know What Keycaps Fit Your Keyboard?

Elevate your keyboard with the handmade wall-e artisan keycap
Elevate your keyboard with the handmade wall-e artisan keycap

Check the switch type of your keyboard

Identifying your keyboard's switch type is important for keycap compatibility. You can find this information in the user manual or by contacting the manufacturer. Most keyboards utilize Cherry MX-style switches with a "+" cross-shaped stem, ensuring compatibility with a wide range of keycaps.

However, if your keyboard uses a different switch type, finding compatible keycaps that match your aesthetic preferences might be more challenging.

Check the switch type of your keyboard to ensure it fits with the keycap (source: redragon shop)
Check the switch type of your keyboard to ensure it fits with the keycap (source: redragon shop)

Check the keycap profile

The keycap profile covers the shape and height of the keycaps. Many manufacturers clearly state the profile (e.g., Cherry, OEM, SA) on the product packaging. Choosing the right profile not only affects aesthetics but also the typing experience. Consider your preference for a flat or sculpted profile, and ensure compatibility with your keyboard and switch type.

The keycaps profile comparison between cherry vs sa vs oem profiles (source: das keyboard)
The keycaps profile comparison between cherry vs sa vs oem profiles (source: das keyboard)

* Note: The best compatibility is south-facing keyboards due to the interference between the keys when using Cherry-profile keycaps with north-facing keyboards.

Check the keyboard layout

Before purchasing keycaps, determine your keyboard's layout (ANSI, ISO-DE, JIS). Standard layouts (ANSI) are most common, but some keyboards have variations in key size and arrangement. Verifying your layout ensures the keycaps you choose have the correct configuration, particularly for keys like Enter, Shift, and Backspace.

Carefully check the keyboard layout to find the size that best suits you (source: keychron)
Carefully check the keyboard layout to find the size that best suits you (source: keychron)

Refer to keycap compatibility websites

To check keycap compatibility with your keyboard, you can use several online resources. Forums and knowledge bases like Deskthority and Geekhack are great places where enthusiasts share detailed specifications. The Reddit mechanical keyboard community is also excellent for asking questions and getting recommendations. Additionally, many websites that sell keycaps provide detailed specifications on their product pages. Always review these details before purchasing to ensure a perfect fit.

You can ask about the compatibility of your keycap on some communities (Source: Redragon Shop)

Where to Buy Best Quality Keycaps?

Numerous online retailers offer a vast selection of keycaps, catering to various preferences and budgets. Before that, check out our informative article The Best Keycap Brands to discover top brands trusted by enthusiasts. Ready to upgrade your keyboard? Let's find the best place to buy your new keycaps: 

Keyboard form factors and layouts
Where to buy the best quality keycaps

Amazon

Well, it's not surprising that Amazon is one of the places to go if you're looking for keycaps or pretty much everything else! You can find lots of options in terms of custom printed keycaps here. Plus, since there are also numerous sellers on Amazon, it is easy to get a new set of keycaps at a reasonable price.

Etsy

Even though Etsy doesn't have a massive community of sellers like Amazon, you will have a whole new keycap shopping experience here.

On Etsy, you will easily come across gorgeous artisan keycaps, many of which are handmade and customized to add a unique touch to your keyboard. However, the price can be a bit higher for individual caps, but it's totally worth spending a little bit extra to have your special keycap, right?

Hirosart

Hirosart is well-known for being the best store for custom and artisan keycaps. Best of all, we create high-quality keycaps that not only look amazing but are also very durable at a super affordable price. So, if you want to find cool artisan custom keycaps like Captain America’s Shield, Galaxy, or Pokemon keycaps, then checking out their site is a must!

Drop

Drop is yet another great marketplace for finding keycaps. Whether you are searching for a full set or just a custom spacebar to add that extra pop to your keyboard, you will find pretty much everything you need here.

KPRepublic

Trusted by the keyboard community, KPrepublic is an online store in China that takes care of all of your keyboard needs, from cases to PCBs. Not to mention their huge collection of custom keycaps for you to choose from!

Mechanicalkeyboards.com

If you're looking for custom keyboards or affordable keycaps, then Mechanicalkeyboard is the place. They offer plenty of keyboard and keycap sets. However, the keycap designs and colors here are quite simple and common. Still, it is one of the best places to browse if you're looking for more keycap options.

Keycapsets.com

Whether you're looking for a standard Cherry MX keyboard set or some cool-themed custom double-shot keycaps, Keycapsets.com will help you find the right keycaps with just a few clicks! Also, this is a perfect place for group buys and high-end keycap sets. You’ll be able to find the latest GMK, novel designs, and the most trendy keycaps on the market.

What Do You Need to Change Your Keycaps?

Whether you just received your new set of keycaps or simply want to check the current keycap profile, this guide will help walk you through each step of how to change your keycaps. Overall, the process is not difficult at all. However, it will take you some time (around 30-45 min) to change a full-sized keyboard. Now, let’s get started!

  • Step 1: Get a keycap puller or DIY one.
  • Step 2: Use the keycap puller to remove keycaps from your keyboard gently.
  • Step 3: Spray an air duster on your switches to clean the keyboard. Then, use a cloth to clean each keycap.
  • Step 4: Connect the large keys with stabilizers.
  • Step 5: Add the rest of the keys to your keyboard.

The Bottom Line

Knowing keycaps are not universal and how different they can be are the key factors to find keycaps that fit your mechanical keyboard. Overall, there is no absolute answer to which keycaps are the best, it all depends on the keyboard you are using and your own preferences. So, our advice is that you should consider every element, from keyboard layout, and stabilizers, to colors thoroughly before purchasing the new keycaps you like.

Tags: