Kailh Box vs Gateron switches: Which one is better?

  • Keycaps 101
  • Posted by: amy-golden
  • Sep 27, 2023

Among the numerous switch brands available, Kailh Box vs Gateron switches have emerged as the top favorites. Each offers its own unique blend, promising a distinct feel and performance. So the question arises: Which is superior? Let's dive into the world of mechanical switches and determine whether Kailh Box or Gateron will emerge as the champion.

Kailh Box vs Gateron switches: Quick Comparison

Kailh box vs gateron switches
Kailh box vs gateron switches

Kailh Box switches: Designed and manufactured by the Chinese company Dongguan Kaihua Electronics, Kailh Box switches have a unique square box design, different from traditional mechanical switches. Kailh Box is also famous for providing many variants with different typing feels to suit the user's typing preferences. Some popular Kailh Box switch options include: Kailh Box Red, Kailh Box White, Kailh Box Jade.

Gateron switches: Gateron switches are manufactured by Gateron company, China. It is famous for its flexibility and variety of switch types, from soft feel types to harder feel types. They are very popular in the mechanical keyboard lover community.Some popular Gateron switch options include: Gateron Red, Gateron Brown, Gateron Black.

Pros Cons
Kailh Box switches
  • The box design is dust and water resistant
  • Durable
  • Smooth keystrokes
  • Wide variety of options
  • Less shaking
  • Unique sound
  • Variety of options
  • Scratches when typing
  • Less widely available
Gateron switches
  • High Quality
  • Smooth experience
  • Compatible with various mechanical keyboards
  • The switch responds quickly
  • Good price
  • Lower durability
  • Cruise response is not pronounced enough
  • May be too loud for some users
  • Key wobbling

 

Kailh Box and Gateron have different features but they are both designed based on Cherry MX switches. Although they cannot bring the perfect experience like the original, with cheaper prices, Kailh Box and Gateron are still considered the best and most popular duplicates of Cherry MX switches.

Kailh Box vs Gateron Switches: What are the differences?

Before analyzing each feature in detail, let's review the important differences between these two types of switches to help you choose the right one for your needs and priorities.

Kailh box heavy switch for diy mechanical keyboard 3 pins
Kailh box heavy switch for diy mechanical keyboard 3 pins
Features Kailh Box

Kailh box

Gateron

Gateron

Shape Box shape (square) Cross-shaped stem  design
Actuation Force 70g 50g
Tactile Feedback A sharper and more pronounced tactile feedback Do not provide tactile feedback
Smoothness Not as smooth as Gateron Smooth keystrokes
Sound Profile Quiet Rather quiet
Durability
  • Higher durability than Gateron
  • Operating life: 80 million times 
  • Durable, long lifespan
  • Operating life: 50 million times
Availability Widely available Widely available
Typing Experience
  • Smooth keystrokes, comfortable and satisfying experience
  • More stable
  • A smooth and consistent typing experience
  • Less stable
Gaming Performance Suitable for gaming Light actuation force, well-regarded for gaming
Price $33.95/ 65pcs $34.99/ 120pcs

*Note: Prices were updated on September 25, 2023 and may change depending on the supplier.

Stem design

Kailh box boxy stem and gateron traditional stem design
Kailh box boxy stem and gateron traditional stem design

Gateron switches use a more traditional Cherry MX-style stem design. This design is less stable than the Kailh Box stem design, but it is also more compatible with a wider range of keycaps. However, Gateron switches have a smaller stem than the original design, so it feels smoother than Cherry MX.

Kailh Box switches have a unique “box” or square body shape. This design is characterized by a cross shape and a boxy (or cylindrical) case. The switch body is enclosed in a box-shaped shell that contributes to increased protection from dust, liquids or other intrusive substances. Therefore, Kailh Box switches have higher durability and overall lifespan than conventional switches.

If you are looking for a switch with a stable and dustproof design, then Kailh Box switches are a good option. If you are looking for a switch with wider keycap compatibility, then Gateron switches are a good option.

Actuation Force

Actuation force statistics table of kailh box and gateron switches
Actuation force statistics table of kailh box and gateron switches

Both Kailh Box and Gateron offer a variety of switches with different actuation forces. Here is an overview of the impact force range of both:

Gateron switches usually have a very wide range of actuation force, from about 35g to 80g or more. Meanwhile, the impact force range of the Kailh Box is shorter, ranging from 40g to 75g.

For switches with the lightest actuation force. While Gatreon's switches provide a comfortable, easy, friction-free typing experience, Kailh Box's switches provide a smooth typing experience with better bounce and deeper bottom response.

Additionally, both Kailh Box and Gateron's most powerful switches deliver powerful mechanical force, stability and realism with every press. However, Kailh Box switches will have clearer tactile feedback and sharper sound than Gateron switches.

If you like lightness and comfort, Gateron will be the right choice for you. On the contrary, if you prefer a tactile feel and clearer sound, the Kailh Box will be better.

Tactile Feedback

Gateron tactile switches
Gateron tactile switches

Kailh Box switches deliver the kind of tactile feedback that is clear and crisp, especially for clicky switches like jade and pink. When the user presses the button, there will be a "click" sound and a clear tactile feeling. This creates a more focused and accurate typing experience.

Gateron also offers switches with Tactile Feedback. However, the feel of Gateron is usually lighter than that of Kailh Box. Gateron switches provide smooth and consistent tactile feedback, especially when using the brown and blue versions. These variations create a slight “bump”, giving a different feeling every time the user presses the button.

In short, Kailh Box tactile switches generally have a clearer feel, while Gateron offers a softer experience. The final choice should be based on your personal preferences and specific requirements.

Smoothness  

Gateron clear switches with the highest smoothness
Gateron clear switches with the highest smoothness

Gateron switches are renowned for their smooth and low-friction design, making typing effortless and efficient. They are often considered superior to Cherry MX switches in terms of smoothness and responsiveness, even without additional lubrication.

On the other hand, Kailh Box switches offer a comfortable typing experience for most users, although some have noted a slightly scratchy or gritty feel, particularly when keys are pressed off-center. However, the switch experience can vary based on individual preferences and usage.

Sound Profile

Check the sound of your switches
Check the sound of your switches

Both Gateron and Kailh Box switches offer various sound configurations for mechanical keyboard enthusiasts. They typically provide three sound levels: quiet, gentle, and clicky, each with its unique characteristics.

Gateron switches are known for their smooth and pleasant typing experience. They incorporate small rubber pads at the stem's top and bottom to dampen sound, resulting in quieter, deeper, and smoother keypresses. If you prefer a tranquil typing experience with soft, muted sounds, Gateron's linear switches are an excellent choice.

Conversely, Kailh Box switches are favored by those who enjoy distinct clicking sounds while typing. The box design minimizes vibrations and enhances overall sound quality. Among Kailh Box switches, the click bar variants are especially popular for their typewriter-like click, delivering a satisfying auditory cue with each keystroke.

Watch the video below to better compare the sound differences between Gateron switches and Kailh Box switches.

Typing Experience

Gateron and kailh box both provide good typing experience
Gateron and kailh box both provide good typing experience

The typing experience with Gateron and Kailh Box switches depends on many different factors, including actuation force, tactile feedback, smoothness, and sound profile.

Gateron is more famous for its smooth, light and fast typing. Gateron's typing-friendly switches are worth trying: G Pro Blue switches, G Pro Green switches, Low profile Optical Blue switches,...

On the other hand, Kailh Box switches offer a sharp and responsive typing experience thanks to their boxy design, providing stability and a quieter typing sound. Some recommended Kailh Box switches for a pleasant typing experience are Kailh Box White, Speed Bronze, and Speed Pink switches.

Gaming Performance

Gateron has the upper hand in gaming
Gateron has the upper hand in gaming

Both Kailh Box switches and Gateron switches have switches that deliver great performance for gaming.

Gateron will have more advantage in gaming experience because Gateron is more famous for its smoothness and responsiveness. The lack of tactile bumps or audible sounds allows for quick key presses without any interference. Additionally, Gateron switches have low actuation force, which can bring about faster key presses. Faster response and reduced finger fatigue during prolonged gaming. Gateron Red, Gateron Brown, Gateron Yellow are the ideal choices that bring high sensitivity to gamers.

Kailh Box switches also provide the same quick response as Gateron switches. However, it has a tactile and clicky variant that provides clearer feedback, aiding precise keystrokes. It also requires more pressure, making it suitable for gamers who prefer clear tactile feedback.The Kailh Box switches suitable for gaming that you should try are BOX Red, BOX White, Box Brown.

However, depending on your preferences and desire for personal experience, you can consider between Kailh box and Gateron. 

Durability

Durability of kailh box switches and gateron switches
Durability of kailh box switches and gateron switches

Kailh Box switches are highly durable, with an impressive 80 - 100 million click lifespan, twice that of Gateron switches. Kailh Box switches also have a unique design that prevents dust and water from entering the switch, making them more durable and easy to clean.

Although the Gateron switch is not as durable as the Kailh Box switch, it is still rated at a good level with 40M click times. They are built with quality materials, designed for extensive use, and feature components that can withstand high keystroke counts without significant performance degradation. The smooth and consistent actuation further ensures long-lasting performance.

Availability

Kailh box switches are less available than gateron switches
Kailh box switches are less available than gateron switches

Gateron switches are a popular choice among mechanical keyboard enthusiasts due to their wide variety of colors and designs, making them compatible with many keyboards

In comparison, Kailh Box switches are relatively less popular than Gateron switches. Although they offer many options, including click, tactile, and linear variations, the range of choices is narrower than Gateron. However, Kailh Box switches are becoming more popular and available thanks to their unique features and benefits.

Price

Price of some kailh box switches
Price of some kailh box switches

Gateron switches have become popular because they strike an excellent balance between cost and functionality, making them an attractive choice for many users. A Gateron switch usually costs from about 0.25 USD to 0.50 USD, depending on the type and color. Buying in bulk can get a discount, making them a more budget-friendly option for those looking to replace their keyboard switches.

Likewise, Kailh Box switches also provide an affordable and cost-effective option for mechanical keyboard enthusiasts. The price of a Kailh switch usually ranges from $0.4 to $1, some types will cost slightly more. With additional features and benefits, Kailh Box switches are still considered reasonably priced.

Kailh Box Linear vs Gateron Linear switches

Kailh box red switches
Kailh box red switches

Kailh Box and Gateron linear switches provide a smooth typing experience with no "bump" feel. However, there are slight differences between the two. Kailh Box Linear provides a comprehensive net feel, creating a gentle flashing sound. On the other hand, Gateron Linear also offers a quiet feel, but can provide a greater flexibility, with a softer strobe sound.

Kailh Box Linear switches:

  • BOX Red Switches
  • BOX Black Switches
  • BOX Dark Yellow Switches

Gateron Linear switches:

  • Gateron Switches: Red, Black, White, Yellow
  • Silent Switches: Black, Red, Yellow, White
  • Low-Profile Switches: Red
  • Ink Switches: Red, Black, Yellow
  • Milk switches: Red, Black, White, Yellow
  • Cap switches: Milky Yellow, Golden Yellow, Milky Brown, Golden Brown, Cap Red
  • Optical Switches: Red, Black, White, Yellow, Silver. 
  • Others switches: Oil King Switch, CJ Switch, North Pole – Yellow, North Pole – Box Red, North Pole – Box Silver, Baby raccoon.
Features Kailh box linear

Kailh box linear

Gateron linear

Gateron linear

Actuation Force 45±10gf 45±15gf
Actuation point 1.8±0.4mm 2±0.6mm
Travel distance 3.6±0.3mm 4±0.6mm
Smoothness Not as smooth as Gateron Smooth keystrokes
Sound Profile Quiet Quiet
Durability Over 80 million times  50 million times
User experience Small pressure, light, easy to operate Smooth, suitable for long-term computer workers
Price $49.99/ 120pcs $16/ 36pcs

*Note: Prices were updated on September 25, 2023 and are subject to change.

Kailh Box Clicky vs Gateron Clicky switches

Kail box navy switches
Kail box navy switches

Kailh Box and Gateron both offer "clicky" switches with distinctive sounds. However, the Kailh Box often delivers a prominent click sound, accompanied by a clear sense of feedback. In contrast, Gateron clicky switches offer flexibility with a lighter clicking feel.

Let's list clicky switches from Kailh box and Gateron and compare their features.

Gateron clicky switches:

  • Gateron Switches: Blue, Green
  • Low-Profile Blue Switches
  • Ink Blue Switches
  • Milk Switches: Blue, Green
  • Cap Blue Switches
  • Optical Blue Switches

Kailh box clicky switches:

  • BOX White Switches
  • BOX Navy Switches
  • BOX Jade Switches
  • BOX Pale Blue Switches
Features Kailh box clicky

Kailh box clicky

Gateron clicky

Gateron clicky

Actuation Force 70±10gf 55±15gf
Actuation point 1.9±0.4mm 2.3±0.6mm
Travel distance 4±0.4mm 4±0.6mm
Smoothness Not as smooth as Gateron Smooth keystrokes
Sound Profile Clicky Loud, clicky
Durability Over 80 million times  50 million times
User experience Easy to press, requires strong impact, enjoyable sound Delivers a satisfying typing experience, heavy force
Price $59/ 90pcs $24/ 35pcs

*Note: Prices were updated on September 25, 2023 and are subject to change.

Kailh Box Tactile vs Gateron Tactile switches

Gateron low-profile brown switches
Gateron low-profile brown switches

Kailh Box and Gateron tactile switches have significant differences. Kailh Box Tactile generally provides a stronger impact feel, with a distinct "bump" when pressed. The sound emitted is also often denser. In contrast, Gateron Tactile provides a smoother feedback experience, with a softer "bump". This creates a softer typing feeling, not too sharp like the Kailh Box. Gateron Tactile tactility is also higher, allowing keys to be pressed more smoothly and easily.

To meet the diverse preferences of customers, Kailh and Gateron have also launched many tactile switch products.

Gateron tactile switches:

  • Gateron Brown Switches
  • Silent Brown Switches
  • Low-Profile Brown Switches
  • Milk Brown Switches
  • Cap Switches: Milky Brown, Golden Brown, Cap Brown
  • Optical Brown Switches
  • Others: Kangaroo switch 59g/63g, Baby kangaroo 

Kailh box tactile switches:

  • BOX Burnt orange Switches
  • BOX Brown
  • BOX Royal
Features Kailh box tactile

Kailh box tactile

Gateron tactile

Gateron tactile

Actuation Force 45±10gf 55±15gf
Actuation point 1.8±0.4mm 2±0.6mm
Travel distance 3.6±0.3mm 4±0.6mm
Smoothness Not as smooth as Gateron Smooth keystrokes
Sound Profile Gentle Gentle
Durability Over 80 million times  50 million times
User experience High stability, very pleasant sound and sensitive touch Delicate touch and smooth operation
Price $35.5/ 72pcs $50/ 105pcs

*Note: Prices were updated on September 25, 2023 and are subject to change.

Conclusion

Overall, the battle between Kailh Box vs Gateron switches seems inconclusive. Both switch brands offer unique advantages, suitable for a variety of preferences and needs of mechanical keyboard users. The best choice for you will depend on your personal style and preferences, as well as the type of keyboard you use or are considering purchasing. Gateron is smoother and softer, while Kailh Box is sharper and faster.

FAQs

Are Kailh Box switches better than Gateron?

It is difficult to determine whether Kailh Box or Gateron is better, because each type of switch will have different advantages and disadvantages. Besides, whether it is good or not depends on each person's needs. Some users may prefer the greater durability and stability of Kailh Box switches, while others may prioritize the smoothness and usability of Gateron switches.

Kailh Box or Gateron switches: Which is better for typing?

Kailh Box switches, with their unique boxy design, provide a stable and tactile typing feel. Meanwhile, Gateron switches are known for their smooth and consistent actuation, providing a comfortable and seamless typing experience. Both types provide a good typing experience, the final decision depends on you.

Kailh Box or Gateron switches: Which is better for gaming?

Both Kailh Box and Gateron switches have earned their popularity among gamers, and the choice between them hinges on individual preference. Some may prefer the crisp response of the Kailh Box, while others find the buttery smoothness of the Gateron to be their ideal gaming experience.

Kailh Box Red or Gateron Red: Which is better?

If you prioritize stability, durability, and some added resistance to environmental factors, the Kailh Box Red may be a better choice. However, if you like a smooth and comfortable typing experience, especially when gaming, Gateron Red could be the preferred choice.

Kailh Box white vs Gateron Blue: Which is better?

Both are clicky switches and both have very smooth action. However, clicky Gateron switches will have better tactile feedback but are also heavier and shakier. Meanwhile, Kailh's clickbar switches have very little tactile feedback but also have much less vibration and a crisp click. It's up to you which type of switch is better.

What are the differences between Kailh Brown and Gateron Brown switches? 

Gateron Brown switches have smoother movement, are easier to use and feel more stable. These switches also provide quietness when moving.

Meanwhile, Kailh Brown switches have a more unique tactile feel, have strong dust resistance, are more durable and are cheaper. But Kailh brown switches are also louder and require more force.

Are Kailh Box switches more durable than Gateron switches?

Kailh Box switches are often considered more durable than standard Gateron switches due to their unique box-shaped design. Kailh Box switches typically provide 80-100M click times. Meanwhile, Gateron's switches usually only have 40-50 M click times.

Which switch is quieter, Kailh Box or Gateron?

Between Kailh Box and Gateron switches, the Gateron switches are generally considered to be quieter, especially the linear variants. Meanwhile, Kailh Box switches, especially clicky variants, often produce a clearer and more audible sound thanks to their unique boxy design.

 

Tags:

Author

I work as a freelance blogger in Seattle, Washington. I've been freelancing full-time for 5 years. I'm interested in anime, resin art, and mechanical keyboards.

amy-golden