Gateron vs. Cherry - Is Gateron better than Cherry?

  • Keycaps 101
  • Posted by: amy-golden
  • Jul 11, 2024

The main distinction in the Gateron vs. Cherry MX switches lies in typing feel, durability, and cost. Gateron switches provide a smoother typing experience and a budget-friendly option, ideal for everyday users.  In contrast, Cherry MX switches offer greater durability and consistency, appealing to users who prioritize long-lasting quality. Let's dive into the details of this Gateron vs. Cherry comparison.

Gateron Switches: A Sneak Peak

Gateron, produced by Huizhou Gateron Electronics Technology Co., Ltd. in Southern China, initially entered the market with Cherry MX clones, making a mark in the mechanical switch industry as an affordable and high-quality alternative. Known for their smooth keystroke experience, Gateron switches have gained popularity, especially among mechanical keyboard enthusiasts. Despite minimal marketing, Gateron continues to expand its reach and brand recognition worldwide.

Gateron series new and classic mechanical keyboard switches (source: amazon)
Gateron series new and classic mechanical keyboard switches (source: amazon)

In recent years, Gateron has introduced new switches that go beyond Cherry MX replicas, including their renowned Zealio switches made in collaboration with ZealPC. The standout feature of Gateron switches lies in their smooth actuation, which many users find superior when comparing Gateron vs Kailh, another Cherry clone brand. Offering durability with a lifespan of 50 million keystrokes, Gateron remains a top choice for those seeking performance and value in a mechanical keyboard switch.

Pros Cons
  • Provides smooth keystrokes
  • Offers affordable pricing
  • Features versatile options
  • Compatible with Cherry MX keycaps
  • Many innovative designs
  • Shorter lifespan than Cherry
  • Lacks Cherry’s consistent build quality
  • Limited availability of high-end keyboards
  • May wear out faster with intense use

If you want to learn more about Gateron switches, check out this post Master Guide to Gateron Switches.

Cherry MX Switches: A Sneak Peak

Cherry, originally founded in the United States in 1953, moved its operations to Germany in 1979, where it established its reputation for precision and quality in keyboard switches. Known for developing the iconic MX switch in the 1980s, Cherry set the industry standard for mechanical keyboards. Cherry MX switches are highly regarded for their reliability, long lifespan, and consistent performance, making them a top choice for professionals and enthusiasts.

Cherry mx switches offer a reliable and precise typing experience (source: voltcave)
Cherry mx switches offer a reliable and precise typing experience (source: voltcave)

Cherry MX switches feature color-coded variants like Red, Blue, and Brown, each offering a distinct typing feel, actuation force, and sound. These switches boast a remarkable durability of up to 100 million keystrokes per key, an investment for users seeking longevity. Despite their higher price point, Cherry remains popular for their premium quality, often used in high-end keyboards. If you're considering alternatives, like Romer-G vs Cherry MX, our comparison can help you decide which is better for you.

Pros Cons
  • Ensures high durability
  • Provides consistent performance
  • Features extensive color options
  • Compatible with most keycaps
  • Widely used and supported as an industry standard
  • High price point
  • Feels stiffer compared to Gateron
  • Limited smoothness in linear models
  • Less affordable for budget users

Read on Cherry MX Switches: A Complete Color review to better understands this type of switch.

Gateron vs Cherry switches: Key differences

What are the differences between gateron vs cherry switches?
What are the differences between gateron vs cherry switches?

Before choosing Gateron or Cherry switches to buy, there are several different factors to take into account.

Overall Feel (Smoothness, Key Feel)

Winner - Gateron

In terms of overall feel, we'll decide which is the most comfortable to use as well as the best for a satisfying gaming and typing experience.

We've found that Gateron switches feel superior overall after testing many switches from both brands.

As previously said, Gateron obviously prioritizes creating a smooth key switch that is pleasant for users. Thus, less resistance or scratching is generated when the keys travel.

On the contrary, Cherry switches will have clear scratchiness at the beginning of use. While some users said this scratchiness lessens after usage, some dissatisfied users find it difficult to get used to the scratchy feeling

After all, Gateron wins for the overall feel since its linear switches are more seamless than Cherry MX.

Affordability

Winner - Gateron

When it comes to affordability, Gateron comes out on top because they are substantially less expensive than Cherry MX switches. The reason can be explained below:

Cherry switches are created in Germany and put through strict testing to confirm their long durability. As a result, the price will be much more expensive. You can buy a pack of 10 pcs switches at the price of $10.80 (see the image below)

Price of cherry mx switches
Price of cherry mx switches

But just with the same price (even lower), you can get a pack of 12 Gateron switches (see image below)

Price of gateron switches
Price of gateron switches

Why can Gateron offer that price level? Standard Gateron switches are produced in China for less expense while copying the Cherry MX design. Besides, what kind of evaluation is done on the switches is also not quite clear.

Overall, standard Gateron switches are often more affordable than Cherry in the aftermarket.

However, in addition to standard switches, both brands offer certain extremely sought-after or limited-edition versions of switches, which may cost a lot of money to collectors.

Durability and Build Quality

Winner - Cherry MX

Cherry MX switches are well known for their durability, lasting up to 100 million keystrokes, with consistent quality control that minimizes variations across switches. It also features reduced key wear and enhanced stability, ensuring minimal wobbling and preventing key chatter. Additionally, Cherry switches come with dust-resistant housings, which add protection from debris, while many Cherry-based keyboards include warranty support to replace faulty switches if needed.

Gateron switches, while typically rated for around 50 million keystrokes, are known for their smoother keystrokes but may experience slight inconsistencies in lubing, smoothness, or spring noise. With smooth keystrokes and a reliable build, Gateron switches are a cost-efficient variant. While both are MX-compatible, Cherry’s quality control and tighter tolerances make it the preferred choice for premium keyboards, especially for users seeking longevity and uniformity across all switches.

Sound

Winner - Tie

Gateron switches make less noise than Cherry MX switches because they are smoother and less scratchy. Many users prefer Gateron Reds, which offer a softer, more muted sound ideal for quiet environments. Besides, Cherry MX switches like the clicky Blue model, produce a sharper and nostalgic typewriter sound that is favored by those who enjoy pronounced feedback.

While Cherry MX Red are quieter than their clicky counterparts, they still tend to be slightly louder than Gateron due to their stiffer feel. Those seeking minimal noise may prefer Cherry’s Silent Red linear switches, which deliver smooth, quiet keypresses without a tactile bump. For an in-depth look at quieter options, explore the quietest keyboard switches. Overall, both brands provide a range of sound profiles, but subtle differences make each suitable for different preferences and uses.

Watch this video to hear how Gateron and Cherry switches differ from each other:

Variety

Winner - Gateron

Cherry MX switches provide a diverse selection catering to different user needs, from loud, clicky types to quieter, smoother options. Cherry MX Blue, for example, is favored by typists for its tactile feedback and audible click, while MX Brown provides a quieter tactile feel suited for office settings. For gamers, Cherry's Speed Silver offers quick actuation and short travel, helping users make rapid keystrokes without added noise.

Gateron presents even greater variety, offering switches across all major categories, plus unique options not found in Cherry’s lineup. Gateron’s Yellow Switch, for instance, is popular among enthusiasts for its smooth, balanced feel, filling a gap between Cherry's Red and Black. Gateron also offers unique variants like the milky housing switches for enhanced LED lighting and the Ink series, known for a smooth keystroke with minimal noise.

Cherry mx and gateron switches offer many choices with many product lines
Cherry mx and gateron switches offer many choices with many product lines

Availability

Winner - Cherry MX

Cherry MX switches are widely available in mid- to high-end mechanical keyboards from major brands like Corsair, Logitech, and Ducky. These switches are often marketed for their durability and precision, attracting users seeking quality and consistency. Cherry-based keyboards are commonly found both in brick-and-mortar stores and major online retailers, making them accessible to a broad audience. If you're wondering about other options, see our guide on Cherry MX Alternatives for a wider selection.

Gateron switches, though popular, are more often found in affordable or enthusiast-level keyboards rather than mainstream models. They’re readily available online through specialized retailers or platforms like Amazon, where users can find a variety of options featuring Gateron’s versatile switch types. This makes Gateron a go-to choice for budget-conscious buyers and DIY enthusiasts looking for customization options.

Modding

Winner - Tie

Both Cherry MX and Gateron switches are popular choices for modding enthusiasts, presenting similar designs that allow for easy customization. These switches can be taken apart with a switch puller or small screwdriver, making lubing and filming accessible to those looking to adjust sound and smoothness.

Gateron switches, particularly the popular Gateron Yellow and Ink series, are often favored for mods due to their smooth base feel, which provides an excellent foundation for customization. Besides, Cherry MX switches, especially the tactile and clicky variants, also attract modders who enjoy experimenting with sound and feel.

Cherry vs. Gateron: Detailed Comparison Of Each Switches

When comparing Cherry vs Gateron switches, each type offers distinct characteristics tailored to various preferences, whether you’re focused on sound, feel, or actuation speed. Here’s an in-depth look at how Cherry vs Gateron stack up in their respective Red, Brown, Blue, Clear, and Silver switches, showcasing how each option caters to different typing needs:

Gateron Switches

Gateron Blue Gateron Red/ Silent Red Gateron Brown/ Silent Brown Gateron Black/ Silent Black Gateron Yellow/ Silent Yellow Gateron Silver/ Silent Silver
Actuation Travel ±0.6mm 2.3 2.0 2.0 2.0 1.1 1.1
Total Travel ±0.4mm 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0
Actuation Force ±15gf 55 45 55 60 35 45
Feel Clicky Linear Tactile Linear Linear Linear

Cherry Switches

Cherry MX Blue Cherry MX Red Cherry MX Brown Cherry MX Black Cherry MX Clear Cherry MX Speed Silver
Actuation Travel ±0.6mm 2.2 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 1.2
Total Travel ±0.4mm 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 3.4
Actuation Force ±15gf 60 45 55 60 65 45
Feel Clicky Linear Tactile Linear Tactile Linear

Cherry Red vs Gateron Red switches 

Gateron red vs cherry red
Gateron red vs cherry red

Gateron Red feels lighter and smoother than Cherry Red, offering a more fluid typing experience ideal for fast-paced gaming. Both Cherry MX Red and Gateron Red switches feature a linear design with a 45g actuation force and 4.0mm travel, but Gateron’s smoothness gives it an edge in comfort. Cherry Red switches, while precise, can feel slightly scratchier to some users.

When comparing Cherry MX Red vs Gateron Yellow switches, both cater to linear switch fans but offer unique experiences. Gateron Yellow requires a bit less force 35g than Cherry, giving it a slightly firmer feel. Gateron yellow vs Cherry red also provides a smoother keystroke, appealing to users who find Cherry too scratchy. For those interested in low-profile options, visit Cherry MX Low Profile Switches for faster typing experiences.

Cherry Blue vs Gateron Blue switches

Gateron blue vs cherry blue
Gateron blue vs cherry blue

Cherry MX Blue vs Gateron Blue switches deliver a clicky, tactile experience favored by typists who enjoy strong auditory feedback. Cherry MX Blue switches require about 60g of actuation force, providing a solid and distinct “click” that typists appreciate for its reliability. With a stable feel and consistent press, Cherry Blues are often chosen for environments where durability and tactile precision are essential.

The Gateron Blue switch, despite having a smaller actuation force of about 55g and an actuation point of 2.3mm, produces a smoother and slightly louder click than the Cherry. This sharper sound appeals to users who want more pronounced auditory feedback. It's a budget-friendly choice for those seeking a clicky switch with enhanced sharpness in sound.

Cherry Brown vs Gateron Brown switches 

Gateron brown vs cherry brown
Gateron brown vs cherry brown

Cherry MX Brown vs Gateron Brown switches are both tactile, offering a subtle bump without the click, ideal for quiet workspaces. Gateron Brown is a bit heavier than Cherry Brown, and while Cherry’s tactile bump is more pronounced, many users find its slightly firmer feel reliable for consistent, stable typing, especially in professional or gaming settings.

In contrast, Gateron Browns provides a smoother, softer actuation that appeals to those seeking a comfortable typing experience for long sessions. With the same 55g actuation force and 2.0mm actuation point, Gateron Browns are often a more budget-friendly option, attracting enthusiasts who prioritize a balance of performance and affordability.

Cherry Clear vs Gateron Clear

Cherry Clear vs Gateron Clear switches differ significantly in feel and intended use. Cherry MX Clear is a heavy tactile switch, requiring around 65g of force for actuation, providing a pronounced tactile bump that many typists enjoy. This heavier feel offers precision for users who prefer a firmer response, ideal for focused typing sessions where feedback is primary.

On the other hand, Gateron Clear is a light linear switch, with only 35g of actuation force, designed for a smooth and effortless press without tactile resistance. This light feel appeals to users who prefer a gentler typing experience, especially during extended gaming or typing sessions. While Cherry Clear is more durable, Gateron Clear’s lighter actuation provides a faster, more relaxed option, making it a cost-effective choice for those seeking fluidity over tactile feedback.

Cherry mx clear vs gateron clear switches
Cherry mx clear vs gateron clear switches

Cherry Silver vs Gateron Silver

Cherry MX Silver switches, also known as Speed Silver, are designed for fast typing and gaming with a lighter actuation force of around 45g and a short travel distance of 3.4mm. This combination allows for quicker keypresses, making them ideal for users who prioritize speed and a light touch, especially in competitive gaming where rapid response is crucial.

Gateron Silver switches, sometimes referred to as Gateron Smoothie Silver, have a similar actuation force of 45g and a longer travel distance of 4.0mm, offering a more substantial feel compared to Cherry’s lighter option. The added resistance in Gateron Silvers suits users who prefer a bit more feedback, adding a balanced typing experience for extended sessions. Both options cater to linear switch fans, with Cherry focused on speed and Gateron on a more durable, robust keystroke.

Cherry mx silver vs gateron silver switches
Cherry mx silver vs gateron silver switches

For linear action, Cherry MX Red and Gateron Red suit gaming, with Gateron Reds offering a smoother press. Tactile typists prefer Cherry Brown for its distinct bump, while Gateron Brown feels softer. Cherry Blue and Gateron Blue provide clicky feedback, with Gateron Blues being louder. Cherry Clear is heavier for precision, and Cherry Silver excels in speed, favored for rapid keystrokes.

Can you put Cherry MX keycaps on Gateron switches?

Yes, most artisan or third-party keycaps are made to be compatible with Gateron and Cherry switches, allowing users to customize their keyboards easily without compatibility concerns.

  • Cross-Shaped Stem Design: Both Cherry MX and Gateron switches feature a cross-shaped (plus-shaped) stem, allowing Cherry keycaps to fit securely onto Gateron switches without any modification.
  • Standardized Dimensions: Cherry MX and Gateron adhere to industry-standard dimensions, which ensures that keycaps from Cherry keyboards will fit smoothly onto Gateron switches and provide a consistent typing feel.
  • Easy Keycap Replacement: Cherry MX keycaps can be swapped onto Gateron switches effortlessly, allowing users to customize their keyboards without compatibility concerns.
  • Wide Variety of Options: Cherry MX keycaps come in numerous styles, colors, and profiles, such as ABS or PBT materials, providing plenty of choices to fit personal preferences.
  • Compatibility with Keycap Sets: Many keycap sets are designed to fit both Cherry MX and Gateron switches, thanks to their shared MX-style stems, making it easy to find a set that enhances your keyboard’s look and feel.

Final Thoughts

Each user will get a preference for certain switch brands. Both Gateron vs Cherry switches is rated as the very best producers of long-lasting, high-quality switches.

Gateron switches are the best affordable option if you are on a budget but still look for something good-quality.

Cherry MX switches will be your best bet if you desire a switch that is extremely reliable and last your entire life.

After all, choosing Gateron or Cherry switches ultimately comes down to your personal preference for the sound and feel; price, and overall experience.

Making a wise decision!

Author

I work as a freelance blogger in Seattle, Washington. I've been freelancing full-time for 5 years. I'm interested in anime, resin art, and mechanical keyboards.

amy-golden

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *